Work it out
You both have the same savings and the same monthly budget. The buyer pays the loan and the upkeep. The renter pays rent and invests their own savings and every euro left over in shares. Who has the most at the end?
We assume a 25-year loan, 5% costs at purchase, 1.5% of the price every year for upkeep, property tax and insurance, 2% indexation of the rent and those costs, and 10% tax on the gains from the shares. At the end the home counts as sold, minus 3% costs. The result depends mostly on the rise in the home’s value: at 2% a year instead of 3%, renting already wins in the example.
Why buying often wins
- Leverage: with €80,000 you buy a home of €300,000. If it rises 3% a year, it grows on the whole amount, not just on your own savings. The interest on your loan is fixed or capped.
- Forced saving: every month you pay off a bit of your loan, whether you feel like it or not. A renter has to invest the difference every month, and few people keep that up.
- A fixed monthly payment: your loan does not change with inflation, your rent does. After 25 years the renter in this example pays a month. You pay nothing more for your loan.
- You live for free after the loan: if you retire without rent or a loan, you need much less income.
- No tax on your own home: if you sell your own home, you generally pay no capital gains tax. On shares you may.
- You are free: you can renovate, let it out or pass it on to your children. A renter cannot.
When renting is smarter
- You will stay less than five to seven years. The costs of buying and selling (see what a home really costs) then eat up your gain.
- You have little savings of your own: a loan with a high monthly payment can make your budget too tight.
- Your job or your family situation is still uncertain.
- The price is very high compared with the rent. In Agimo, compare the price per m² with the rents in the same area.
What the calculation does not show
Major works, such as a new roof or an energy renovation, are not counted. Shares can fall for years, and so can a home. The result depends mostly on the rent, the interest rate and how long you stay. Change the figures above, including those that favour renting.
Want to know what your home costs? Open the app and look at the monthly payment on each home. A good offer helps too: read how to make an offer.